IndieRF Stability Circles
Stability circles, K and μ from an .s2p
The synthetic FET below has μ = 0.109 at 500 MHz and is unconditionally stable only from 8.68 GHz to 15.1 GHz. Drop your own .s2p to read K, μ and μ′ at every point, then pick a frequency and see which loads and sources keep it stable: the stable side of each circle is shaded.
IndieRF synthetic FET (common source, gm 60 mS), simulated by the IndieRF Schematic Simulator; the same file as the S-parameter Viewer's amplifier example.
Which side of the circle is stable
Look at the chart centre first. A matched load is Γ_L = 0, and there Γ_in = S11, so the centre is stable when |S11| < 1. The stable loads are then on the same side of the circle as the centre. When |S11| > 1 the centre is unstable and the stable loads are on the far side. The source plane works the same way with Γ_S and |S22|.
Both rules come down to one sign. The inside of the load circle is stable when |S22|² < |Δ|² and the outside when |S22|² > |Δ|². When the two are equal the circle has opened into a straight line, and the page draws the line and shades the stable side of it.
Definitions
- Δ = S11·S22 − S12·S21
- K = (1 − |S11|² − |S22|² + |Δ|²) / (2·|S12·S21|)
- Load side: μ = (1 − |S11|²) / (|S22 − Δ·S11*| + |S12·S21|). Source side: μ′ = (1 − |S22|²) / (|S11 − Δ·S22*| + |S12·S21|).
- Load (output) circle, drawn in the Γ_L plane where |Γ_in| = 1: C_L = (S22 − Δ·S11*)* / (|S22|² − |Δ|²), r_L = |S12·S21| / ||S22|² − |Δ|²|, with Γ_in = S11 + S12·S21·Γ_L / (1 − S22·Γ_L).
- Source (input) circle, drawn in the Γ_S plane where |Γ_out| = 1: C_S = (S11 − Δ·S22*)* / (|S11|² − |Δ|²), r_S = |S12·S21| / ||S11|² − |Δ|²|, with Γ_out = S22 + S12·S21·Γ_S / (1 − S11·Γ_S).
The load circle limits Γ_L, the reflection the load presents to port 2, and keeps the input reflection |Γ_in| below 1. The source circle limits Γ_S, the reflection the source presents to port 1, and keeps |Γ_out| below 1. The two circles live in different planes, so the page draws them on two charts.
One number for the verdict
The 2-port is unconditionally stable when K > 1 and |Δ| < 1, which is the same test as μ > 1. With |S11| < 1, μ is also the distance from the chart centre to the nearest unstable load. The FET example has μ = 1.024 at 10 GHz, so its closest bad load sits just off the chart at |Γ_L| = 1.024. It clears 1 from 8.68 GHz to 15.1 GHz and drops to μ = 0.109 at 500 MHz, where the page opens.
To design an amplifier from the file, Amplifier Design opens the same FET with Γ_S and Γ_L on two charts, shades the same stable sides, and reads gain and NF. The S-parameter Viewer plots the same K and μ beside gain and MAG, and Smith Chart & Matching builds the match once Γ_S and Γ_L are on the stable side.
The note Stability circles: which side is stable, then LNA gain vs NF works the 3 GHz and 5 GHz typed points, where the stable side flips with |S11|, and then trades gain for noise on the FET at 10 GHz.
Limits
Small signal at one bias: the circles come from the file's S-parameters and nothing else. A device stable at every point in the file can still oscillate at a frequency the file does not cover. Between points the page interpolates μ only to place its crossings of 1. The chart centre is the file's reference impedance.
Checked against scikit-rf 2.2 (Network.stability and Network.stability_circle) to 1e-9, and against hand values in exact fractions for the six typed cases. References: D. M. Pozar, Microwave Engineering, 4th ed., §12.3; G. Gonzalez, Microwave Transistor Amplifiers, 2nd ed., §3.3; M. L. Edwards and J. H. Sinsky, "A new criterion for linear 2-port stability using geometrically derived parameters," IEEE Trans. MTT, vol. 40, no. 12, 1992.
The six typed cases
Typed values, one point per case, so each can be checked by hand. Not a device.
| Point | S11 | S12 | S21 | S22 | Case |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 GHz | j0.3 | 0.05 | 2 | −j0.3 | Unconditionally stable |
| 2 GHz | −0.5 | j0.2 | −j2 | −j0.9 | |S11| < 1, centre outside the load circle |
| 3 GHz | j0.75 | 0.2 | 1 + j2 | −0.8 | |S11| < 1, centre inside the load circle |
| 4 GHz | 1.2 | −0.1 | 2 | −j0.9 | |S11| > 1, centre outside the load circle |
| 5 GHz | −1.2 | j0.2 | −2 | 0.1 + j0.8 | |S11| > 1, centre inside the load circle |
| 6 GHz | 0.6 | 0.24 − j0.4 | 2 | 0.8 | |S22| = |Δ|: the load circle is a straight line |
Checked against scikit-rf: the cases, the tolerance and what the check does not cover.