Microstrip line
- Geometry
- A 1.5 mm line on 0.8 mm FR-4 (εr 4.4) under 8 mm of air, 10 mm long, wall to wall, at 1 GHz.
- Reference
- A 2-D quasi-static solve of the same box cross-section, converged to 0.005%, plus the Kirschning-Jansen dispersion increment (published to 0.6%; at 1 GHz the increment is 0.2% of εeff).
- Box and cell
- 10 by 12.5 mm, lid 8.8 mm, 50 µm, stop 1 GHz, 111 unknowns
- Z0: ours 50.42 Ω, reference 50.26 Ω, error +0.32%, gate within 0.5%, pass25 µm cells: 50.32 Ω (+0.11%)
- εeff: ours 3.295, reference 3.301, error −0.18%, gate within 0.5%, pass25 µm cells: 3.296 (−0.15%)
Z0 on 100, 50 and 25 µm cells: 50.625 Ω, 50.424 Ω and 50.316 Ω. Richardson limit 50.190 Ω, observed order 0.89 where about 1 is expected. Convergence plot
Stripline
- Geometry
- A 1.5 mm strip centred in 1.6 mm of FR-4 (εr 4.4) between the floor and the lid, at 1 GHz.
- Reference
- Cohn's closed form, exact for a zero-thickness strip; εeff is εr exactly.
- Box and cell
- 10 by 12.5 mm, lid 1.6 mm, 50 µm, stop 1 GHz, 111 unknowns
- Z0: ours 32.69 Ω, reference 32.57 Ω, error +0.36%, gate within 1%, pass25 µm cells: 32.61 Ω (+0.12%)
- εeff: ours 4.398, reference 4.400, error −0.05%, gate within 0.5%, pass25 µm cells: 4.398 (−0.05%)
Z0 on 100, 50 and 25 µm cells: 32.835 Ω, 32.688 Ω and 32.609 Ω. Richardson limit 32.517 Ω, observed order 0.89 where about 1 is expected. Convergence plot
Stripline at 5 GHz, in 50 Ω
- Geometry
- The same stripline, 7 mm long, read as S in 50 Ω at 5 GHz.
- Reference
- Exact: Cohn's Z0 and εeff = εr give S of a 7 mm line in 50 Ω.
- Box and cell
- 7 by 12.5 mm, lid 1.6 mm, 50 µm, stop 5 GHz, 189 unknowns
- |S21|: ours 0.9160, reference 0.9148, error +0.0012, gate within ±0.002, pass
- |S11|: ours 0.4013, reference 0.4040, error −0.0027, gate within ±0.005, pass
|S21| on 100, 50, 25 and 12.5 µm cells: 0.9178, 0.9160, 0.9152 and 0.9146. Richardson limit 0.9136, observed order 0.60 where about 1 is expected. Convergence plot
Edge-coupled microstrip pair
- Geometry
- Two 1.5 mm lines 0.4 mm apart on the same FR-4, 10 mm long, at 1 GHz.
- Reference
- A 2-D quasi-static solve of the same box plus the Kirschning-Jansen increment. The open-space Kirschning-Jansen 1984 fit claims about 1%.
- Box and cell
- 10 by 14.4 mm, lid 8.8 mm, 50 µm, stop 1 GHz, 222 unknowns
- Z0 even: ours 58.72 Ω, reference 58.62 Ω, error +0.17%, gate within 1%, pass25 µm cells: 58.63 Ω (+0.02%)
- Z0 odd: ours 40.13 Ω, reference 39.75 Ω, error +0.96%, gate within 1%, pass25 µm cells: 39.97 Ω (+0.55%)
- εeff even: ours 3.525, reference 3.535, error −0.29%, gate within 1%, pass25 µm cells: 3.525 (−0.26%)
- εeff odd: ours 2.946, reference 2.946, error −0.00%, gate within 1%, pass25 µm cells: 2.946 (−0.01%)
Z0 even on 100, 50 and 25 µm cells: 58.887 Ω, 58.720 Ω and 58.630 Ω. Richardson limit 58.526 Ω, observed order 0.89 where about 1 is expected. Convergence plot
Open-ended line resonance
- Geometry
- A 20.2 mm line from the port wall to an open end, the first series resonance near 2 GHz.
- Reference
- The box line's εeff over the line plus its open-end extension, taken two ways: the Kirschning-Jansen-Koster fit (about 2.5% of the extension, 0.04% of the frequency) and a 3-D quasi-static solve of the same box.
- Box and cell
- 25.7 by 12.5 mm, lid 8.8 mm, 50 µm, stop 2.4 GHz, 286 unknowns
- Resonance, KJK open end: ours 2.009 GHz, reference 2.007 GHz, error +0.09%, gate within 0.5%, pass
- Resonance, 3-D open end: ours 2.009 GHz, reference 2.006 GHz, error +0.16%, gate within 0.5%, pass
openEMS of the same box with a feed in place of the port wall, 3 meshes up to 1.24 million cells: first series resonance 2.009 GHz. Ours is +0.004% from it, against a rule of 0.5%. openEMS moves +0.020% between its two finest meshes.
Resonance on 100, 50 and 25 µm cells: 2.0099 GHz, 2.0090 GHz and 2.0085 GHz. Richardson limit 2.0078 GHz, observed order 0.84 where about 1 is expected. Convergence plot
Series gap
- Geometry
- Two 5 mm lines, 1.5 mm wide, with a 0.2 mm gap between them, |Y21| at 1 GHz.
- Reference
- A 3-D quasi-static method-of-moments solve of the same box, ±0.3%. Ours is the Richardson value from 50, 25 and 12.5 µm cells. Garg and Bahl's closed form reads 8.4% lower here and is not used.
- Box and cell
- 10.2 by 12.5 mm, lid 8.8 mm, Richardson on 50, 25, 12.5 µm, stop 1 GHz
- Cells
- 50 µm 0.2732 mS, 25 µm 0.2780 mS, 12.5 µm 0.2805 mS
- |Y21|: ours 0.2831 mS, reference 0.2851 mS, error −0.68%, gate within 2.5%, pass
openEMS of the same layout with no end walls, 4 meshes up to 5.78 million cells: |Y21| 0.2948 mS. Ours is −3.94% from it, against a rule of 2%. openEMS moves +0.11% between its two finest meshes.
|Y21| on 100, 50, 25 and 12.5 µm cells: 0.26381 mS, 0.27318 mS, 0.27804 mS and 0.28053 mS. Richardson limit 0.28315 mS, observed order 0.96 where about 1 is expected. Convergence plot
Shunt open stub (tee)
- Geometry
- A 1.5 mm through line with a 20.2 mm open stub off its side, the notch near 2 GHz.
- Reference
- Hammerstad's 1981 tee, the open-end extension and the box line's εeff. The tee's reference-plane shift is not well quantified; ±5% of it moves the notch ±0.8%.
- Box and cell
- 12 by 32.7 mm, lid 8.8 mm, 50 µm, stop 3 GHz, 1014 unknowns
- Notch: ours 2.036 GHz, reference 2.032 GHz, error +0.19%, gate within 1.5%, pass
Notch on 50 µm cells with the subsection length divided by 1, 2 and 4: 2.03593 GHz, 2.03591 GHz and 2.03594 GHz. The levels do not move one way and span 0.0016%, so no Richardson limit is given. Convergence plot
Right-angle bend
- Geometry
- A 1.5 mm line that turns 90 degrees in a 10 by 10 mm box, 5 mm arms, |S11| in 50 Ω.
- Reference
- Hammerstad's bend model between two arms of the box line. Its C and L are published to about 5% and 3%.
- Box and cell
- 10 by 10 mm, lid 8.8 mm, 50 µm, stop 5 GHz, 536 unknowns
- |S11|: ours 0.0166, reference 0.0122, error +0.0044, gate within ±0.01, pass
|S11| on 50, 25 and 12.5 µm cells: 0.01659, 0.01739 and 0.01775. Richardson limit 0.01805, observed order 1.14 where about 1 is expected. Convergence plot
Step in width
- Geometry
- 6 mm of 1.5 mm line, then 6 mm of 0.8 mm line, |S21| in 50 Ω at 5 GHz.
- Reference
- Hand model: the two box lines with the Garg and Bahl step (its C about 10%, its L about 5%). openEMS of the same layout below.
- Box and cell
- 12 by 12 mm, lid 8.8 mm, 100 µm, stop 5 GHz, 368 unknowns
- |S21|: ours 0.9521, reference 0.9540, error −0.0019, gate within ±0.003, pass
openEMS of the same layout with no end walls, 3 meshes up to 2.02 million cells: S11, S21 and S22 at 1 to 5 GHz differ from ours by 0.0096 at most (S22 at 2 GHz), against a rule of 0.02. |S21| is within 0.10% and its phase within 0.23 degrees. openEMS moves 0.0008 between its two finest meshes.
|S21| on 100, 50, 25 and 12.5 µm cells: 0.9521, 0.9530, 0.9536 and 0.9538. Richardson limit 0.9539, observed order 1.61 where about 1 is expected. At 100 µm an edge of the layout is off the cell grid and the mesher rounds it, so that level also changes the geometry. Convergence plot
Low-impedance section
- Geometry
- A 6 mm wide, 6 mm long section between two 1.5 mm feeds, its first mode with the ports shorted.
- Reference
- openEMS of the same closed box, finest of four meshes, which moved it 0.04%.
- Box and cell
- 16 by 12.5 mm, lid 8.8 mm, 50 µm, stop 5 GHz, 1036 unknowns
- Mode: ours 3.358 GHz, reference 3.365 GHz, error −0.21%, gate within 1%, pass
Mode on 100, 50 and 25 µm cells: 3.3547 GHz, 3.3578 GHz and 3.3591 GHz. No Richardson limit is given, because an edge of the layout is off the 100 µm grid and the mesher rounds it. The levels span 0.13%. Convergence plot
Stepped-impedance resonator
- Geometry
- 10 mm of 1.5 mm line, then 10 mm of 0.75 mm line to an open end, the first zero of Im Zin.
- Reference
- openEMS of the same closed box (finest of four meshes, within 0.05% of the next), and a hand value from the box lines, the Garg and Bahl step and the open-end fit.
- Box and cell
- 25 by 12.5 mm, lid 8.8 mm, 50 µm, stop 2.4 GHz, 460 unknowns
- Resonance, openEMS: ours 2.297 GHz, reference 2.292 GHz, error +0.22%, gate within 1%, pass
- Resonance, hand: ours 2.297 GHz, reference 2.293 GHz, error +0.18%, gate within 1.5%, pass
Resonance on 50 µm cells with the subsection length divided by 1, 2 and 4: 2.2973 GHz, 2.2971 GHz and 2.2970 GHz. Richardson limit 2.2970 GHz, observed order 1.27 where about 2 is expected. At 100 and 50 µm an edge of the layout is off the cell grid and the mesher rounds it, so the cell sizes also change the geometry. Convergence plot
Wide section away from the wall
- Geometry
- A 4 mm wide, 6 mm long section 3 mm from each port wall on 1.5 mm feeds, S from 1 to 7 GHz.
- Reference
- openEMS of the same channel with no end wall at all, so neither its port nor ours enters. The number is the largest complex difference of S.
- Box and cell
- 12 by 12 mm, lid 8.8 mm, 100 µm, stop 15 GHz, 2139 unknowns
- Largest |ΔS|: ours 0.0105, gate under 0.012, pass
Largest |ΔS| on 100, 50, 25 and 12.5 µm cells: 0.01053, 0.009858, 0.009472 and 0.009244. Richardson limit 0.008917, observed order 0.76 where about 1 is expected. At 100 µm an edge of the layout is off the cell grid and the mesher rounds it, so that level also changes the geometry. Convergence plot