ADS-B LNA first vs filter first: 2.33 dB better NF for 2.5 dB less P1dB headroom

With the same five parts, moving the LNA ahead of the SAW filter takes system NF from 4.99 to 2.65 dB and raises SNR at −85 dBm by 2.33 dB. The cost is 2.5 dB of blocker headroom: the chain's input P1dB falls from 3.0 to 0.5 dBm, because the SAW's loss no longer sits ahead of the LNA.

Open LNA firstOpen filter first

Row at the SDRLNA firstFilter first
Cumulative NF2.65 dB4.99 dB
SNR23.31 dB20.98 dB
Noise Floor (Input)−108.31 dBm−105.98 dBm
Cumulative Gain44.00 dB44.00 dB
Cumulative IIP311.50 dBm14.00 dBm
Cumulative IP1dB0.50 dBm3.00 dBm
P1dB Headroom85.50 dB88.00 dB

Blocker headroom here is the budget's P1dB Headroom row: the chain's input P1dB (Cumulative IP1dB) minus the −85 dBm carrier, both at the antenna. The template's SAW is a scalar 2.5 dB at every frequency, so this is an in-band blocker. A real SAW also rejects an out-of-band blocker by its stopband rejection before the LNA sees it, which is the reason to keep the filter first next to a strong transmitter.

LNA first

NF 2.65 dB: Antenna cable, 1.5 dB loss sets it, 1.10 dB better if ideal, 49% of the excess noise.

IIP3 11.50 dBm: LNA, NF 0.8 dB, 20 dB gain, OIP3 30 dBm is the only rated stage.

1090 MHzantenna, −85 dBmaircraftAntenna cable,1.5 dB lossLNA, NF 0.8 dB,20 dB gain, OIP330 dBmSAW band-pass1090 MHz, 2.5 dBlossCable toreceiver, 2 dBlossSDR receiver, NF6 dB, 30 dB gain
−150−100−50050100dBm1090 MHz anten…Antenna cable,…LNA, NF 0.8 dB…SAW band-pass …Cable to recei…SDR receiver, …
Carrier in channelNoise in channelCumulative OP1dBCumulative OIP3Output referred, after each block.

ADS-B 1090 MHz receiver, LNA first: 2.65 dB NF

Filter first

NF 4.99 dB: SAW band-pass 1090 MHz, 2.5 dB loss sets it, 1.86 dB better if ideal, 51% of the excess noise.

IIP3 14.00 dBm: LNA, NF 0.8 dB, 20 dB gain, OIP3 30 dBm is the only rated stage.

1090 MHzantenna, −85 dBmaircraftAntenna cable,1.5 dB lossSAW band-pass1090 MHz, 2.5 dBlossLNA, NF 0.8 dB,20 dB gain, OIP330 dBmCable toreceiver, 2 dBlossSDR receiver, NF6 dB, 30 dB gain
−150−100−50050100dBm1090 MHz anten…Antenna cable,…SAW band-pass …LNA, NF 0.8 dB…Cable to recei…SDR receiver, …
Carrier in channelNoise in channelCumulative OP1dBCumulative OIP3Output referred, after each block.

ADS-B 1090 MHz receiver, filter first: 4.99 dB NF

All solved cascade examples

Question about this comparison, or a correction?